Talk:Eric Dick (lawyer)

Latest comment: 2 years ago by Starpizza in topic HCDE Tenure

HCDE Tenure

edit

There is a problem in the article with 90% of the content relating to HCDE.

  • First off all, most of this belongs on the Harris County Department of Education article, not here.
  • Secondly, although this article takes great pains to assure the reader that Eric Dick was much involved in this HCDE work, almost none of the sources even mention his name. So this is all undue focus on one individual in the work of a public body, a focus that is not shared by sources and cannot be verified. For all the reader knows, Dick could have almost nothing to do with every one of them. If the sources do not single him out for a mention, then Wikipedia shouldn't either.

While it is, of course, important to mention Dick's role in this body, and maybe even summarise what has occurred there during his tenures, the extensive detail is unwarranted on this article, and the allocation of credit is not verified by sources.

This section should be drastically cut back. Escape Orbit (Talk) 10:11, 19 August 2024 (UTC) Reply

You both make good points 2600:100D:B087:9BB8:1DA5:CEFC:D912:6124 (talk) 02:19, 21 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
I think escape orbit is correct here 4.4.168.186 (talk) 18:18, 21 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Respectfully disagree Starpizza (talk) 02:55, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Who are you? Bjan Anders (talk) 03:02, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@99.165.93.115 If the sources do not mention Dick's involvement in these examples of HCDE's work, then they have no business being here. It's as simple as that. Otherwise, perhaps we can put them in context by suggesting that they happened despite his involvement, thus explaining why he is not mentioned? I'm joking, of course, because that would be extrapolation away from the sources, in exactly the same way that the article does currently by suggesting they are all thanks to him. Neither is acceptable. Escape Orbit (Talk) 22:09, 21 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Just made this account so no longer 4.4.168.186 going forward and we can more transparently arrive at consensus. Agreed with Escape Orbit here as well. Bjan Anders (talk) 23:12, 21 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
You’re not addressing the issues raised.
Also, your responses are 99.99% generative AI… Bjan Anders (talk) 02:53, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
I read it as should go over it line by line. Starpizza (talk) 02:57, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
What? Bjan Anders (talk) 03:00, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Read, research, then edit. Starpizza (talk) 03:05, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Right.. we did the first two. So you agree we should now remove the HCDE portions that do not involve Eric? Bjan Anders (talk) 03:08, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
No. It doesn't appear you've gone through it line by line. Also I fail to see where any research was done. Starpizza (talk) 03:15, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Starpizza No, wrong way about. The contributing editor is responsible for doing that before adding the content. It's not everyone else's job to research unsourced claims. Escape Orbit (Talk) 05:13, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
You're mistaken. Wikipedia's [Verifiability policy](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Verifiability) makes it everyone's job to ensure accuracy. Mass deletion of unsourced content violates policy; instead, use [“citation needed”](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Citation_needed) to allow others to verify. Responsibility is shared, not just on the original editor. Starpizza (talk) 09:32, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
For a day old account you bizarrely seem to think you're in a position to teach others about Wikipedia policy. Please take some time to read actual policy ("The burden to demonstrate verifiability lies with the editor who adds or restores material") instead of stuff you've made up. While you are doing that, I'm off to add "Eric Dick is a secret Democrat. [citation needed]" to the article, safe in the knowledge that you won't remove it, and it's your job to find something to verify it. --Escape Orbit (Talk) 12:15, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
There is no reason to call names or be rude. This is existing material on a wiki page. Starpizza (talk) 15:20, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Nobody called you any names, and it’s existing material because someone put it there with the same approach to supporting evidence as @Escape Orbit’s “secret Democrat” example. Bjan Anders (talk) 15:50, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Bjan, I appreciate your input, but I want to clarify that there was indeed name-calling in the previous comment. Escape Orbit said, “For a day-old account, you bizarrely seem to think you’re in a position to teach others about Wikipedia policy.” Referring to someone’s behavior as “bizarre” is name-calling, and it’s not constructive. We’re here to work together on improving content, not to question each other’s credibility or intentions in a dismissive way. Let’s keep the discussion focused on the content and avoid making it personal. Starpizza (talk) 17:03, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Starpizza I referred to your comment as bizarre, being totally incorrect, yet very confidently made. So indeed, now that we have established that your claim that unsourced content cannot be removed, but must be "researched", is bogus, we can, as you correctly observe, focus on that content. This is content that has repeatedly been challenged yet repeatedly restored by single purpose accounts. So any claim to it being there by consensus and deserving to be kept is groundless. Now, if you cannot produce reliable sources that verifies and justifies all this work by a public body being credited to one individual, we can get down to replacing it and agreeing on what would be a balanced and sourced summarisation of his work there. Some of the content could also be considered being moved to the appropriate article, where it properly belongs. Escape Orbit (Talk) 19:37, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Second time? Does that mean you are @Starpizza? Bjan Anders (talk) 05:51, 24 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Please be respectful. I understand that's a hard ask. It's a collaborative effort. Starpizza (talk) 11:58, 26 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Scott free0011 I'm sorry if you find my tone dismissive. How would you describe it when someone's very first contributions, in a new enviroment, are to tell others there that they're wrong, and what they should be doing, with confidently incorrect claims? Seems bizarre to me. Some might even think it rude to, and dismissive of, those others.
My sarcastic comment was merely a humorous attempt to illustrate the folly of the proposed interpretation of policy. A clear, and memorable, example always helps clarify things, don't you think? Wikipedia policy is thorough, sound and exhaustedly reviewed. It is always has good reason for being as it is, even when it initially may appear to be unfair or counter intuitive to new editors. Escape Orbit (Talk) 16:23, 24 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Scott free0011 I'm sorry, but I'm not reading all that, because your approach is completely backwards. If you want something to be in the article then the burden for supporting it with verifiable sources is on you. It is not everyone's else's responsibility to search for sources to support what you have added. Nor does the content get to stay until such sources are found. If you want this article to highlight Dick's leading and personal role in these projects, produced sources that do that.
And stop trying to bludgeon discussion with screeds of AI generated waffle. Escape Orbit (Talk) 05:08, 22 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
I don't read your responses when it's obvious that it is acres of fanciful extrapoloation on Wikipedia policies. We do not need to read your interpretaion of policy, and this talk page does not need to document it. (Policy is already fully documented. I guarantee there is nothing special about this article that policy doesn't already cover.) When I also suspect you've not even written most of it yourself, then you bet, I'm not going to waste my time reading it. If you have written it, then I urge you to learn to express yourself far more concisely.
Here is, concisely, the position;
You, and a number of other single purpose editors, have placed in this article claims that the sources do not support.
If the sources do not even mention someone, then they can not be used to support claims about that person.
Other editors have no obligation to research, or investigate, these claims. Were this not the case then, as I illustrated above, articles would contain dubious material, while those that wrote it demand it be retained until someone finds a way of verifying it, if that were even possible. This is why Wikipedia rightly places the burden on the contributer and those who wish to retain it.
We do not need to concern ourself with whether these claims accurately and fairly treat the article subject or not. They are unsourced, and the contributing editor has been unable to source them. So they get removed. Problem solved. If that means a chunk of the article subject's work doesn't get coverage, then that suggests that it is work that is not notable in Wikipedia's terms. If and when reliable sources decide to cover it, only then can Wikipedia include it. It's that easy.
A lot of what has been suggested above regarding "research" is basically original research, which is not permitted on Wikipedia. Viewing recordings of meetings, for instance, to gauge involvement in projects, is original research. No conclusions or content can be based on this.
Combining sources to support a claim, such as newspaper coverage with primary sources like meeting minutes, is original synthesis, and is equally not permissible.
Unsourced existing material isn't due any more consideration than unsourced new material. Especially when that existing material has already been repeatedly challenged and restored.
You have also added to this article photographs that you haven't accounted for and are, by your own explanation, improperly licenced. If this isn't resolved, these images should also be removed.
Details about the work of the HCDE properly belongs on the Harris County Department of Education article. Currently we have the ridiculous situation where this article contains more detail about the HCDE than the HCDE article itself.
--Escape Orbit (Talk) 16:48, 23 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Scott free0011 Again I have to correct your fundamental errors regarding Wikipedia policy. There is no shared responsibility for verifying unsourced content. The only shared responsibility is in ensuring that content in the article is verifiable. There's a difference. Editors may choose to assist in sourcing that which cannot be verified, but it is not a responsibility. There is also no requirement that unsourced content must be kept to be fair to the article subject. Wikipedia's primary concern is verifiability, not truth. Other editors may choose to flag it. and give it a chance to be verified. But this is content that has been repeatedly challenged in its claims and scope, and yet has gotten no better. It's had its chance. If you think it can be sourced, then feel free to take all the time you need to gather sources, and restore the content at a later date. Perhaps the other editors who have taken an interest in retaining this content can assist you.
You uploaded photographs to Wikipedia claiming they were your own work and that you owned the copyright on them. Now you say that they are public domain. Therefore the licence recorded on them, by your own admission, is incorrect. Please fix the licensing on these photos. It would also help if you could explain where you obtained them in the public domain.
I'm sorry if you find my direct approach upsetting. I find your insistence in talking around the issues put to you, at great length, frustrating. I ask you again; please either source the claims you are wanting retained on the article, or remove them. Please either licence the images correctly, explaining where they came from, or remove them. Otherwise, please stop reverting attempts by others to bring the article in line with Wikipedia policy. If there is more to be added to the article about Dick's work at the HCDE then there is no limit to the time it can be added, properly sourced. Escape Orbit (Talk) 15:43, 24 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
And I urge you to stop talking about the root issues and address them. The images that are incorrectly licensed are the photos you uploaded and added to this article. You yourself initially said you owned copyright on them, and then later said they were public domain, created by a public employee in the course of their work for HCDE. How can they be both? The content has been repeatedly challenged, you have repeatedly been given the chance to fix it, but have done nothing but fill this talk page. Your views about collaboration do not trump the need for Wikipedia content to be verifiable, a core policy, or the responsibility of the contributor to do the verifying. Collaboration does not mean "I make a claim, and then someone else should find a way to show it can be verified, and it must not be removed until such time". That's not how it works. --Escape Orbit (Talk) 11:08, 27 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Eric_Dick_HCDE.png#mw-jump-to-license This one Bjan Anders (talk) 04:27, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Board_President_Eric_Dick.png#mw-jump-to-license Also this one
and with all due respect, you have not uploaded any pictures other than hcde pictures with improper licensing or you are likely conflicted with respect to the subject.
https://commons.m.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Team_of_Eight.jpg
What about this one? Bjan Anders (talk) 04:33, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Scott free0011 Still filling the talk page with text no-one is reading, still not actually fixing the issues on the article. If your text isnt AI generated, I can only observe that you are wasting a great deal of time that could be more productively and enjoyably spent improving Wikipedia. Escape Orbit (Talk) 06:55, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
So if you took the photos, then how are you not conflicted? Bjan Anders (talk) 04:02, 30 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Dear Bjan Anders,
Thank you for raising your concern about potential conflicts of interest. I’d like to clarify how taking photographs does not, in itself, constitute a conflict of interest according to Wikipedia’s policies.
Addressing Conflict of Interest Through Wikipedia Policy:
Wikipedia’s Conflict of Interest (COI) policy is designed to prevent editors from using Wikipedia to promote their own interests or those of people with whom they have a close personal or professional relationship. However, simply taking photographs at a public event or meeting does not create a conflict of interest. According to the policy, a conflict of interest typically arises when an editor writes about a topic with which they have a close connection or stands to benefit personally from the content they contribute.
In this case, taking photographs at public events is a standard practice for documenting such events and does not inherently suggest any bias or conflict. The COI policy does not preclude editors from contributing content they have documented themselves, such as photographs, as long as the content is presented neutrally and complies with Wikipedia’s verifiability and neutrality standards. Scott free0011 (talk) 12:32, 30 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Scott free0011 This is the third story you've offered to explain those photographs, and each time it's still not added up. By your the description, that you provided, some photographs were taken at a "retreat" during the COVID19 pandemic. These are not photographs at a public meeting taken by a member of the public. They are staged photographs taken with the active involvement of the subjects, by someone known to, or employed, by them. This wouldn't be a problem, except you've exhibited bad faith throughout your involvement in this article by repeatedly denying or obfuscating the nature of your relationship to the article subject, and using AI to exhaustively extend discussion. I've already explained the problems with the content (use of primary sources, sources that never mention Dick) and you've already acknowledged them. Now fix them. I am also not going to continue to engage in discussion with obviously AI generated text. It's incredibly insulting to other editors for you to continue to do this when asked to stop. You never actually deny you're doing it, do you? You just generate another six paragraphs of the same bluster. Escape Orbit (Talk) 06:54, 30 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
Should we make the necessary edits now? Bjan Anders (talk) 04:21, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
What edits? I do not agree with mass deletion. There were edit suggestions made in the above topics that you've both ignored. Starpizza (talk) 07:29, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
If you have any well-sourced improvements to the article then, please, go ahead and make them. But please do not add content that relies on combining sources to make a claim not in any one source, or claims about Dick that cite sources that do not even mention him. Thanks. --Escape Orbit (Talk) 08:59, 29 August 2024 (UTC)Reply
@Bjan Anders No one agreed to delete the entire election section. Scott free0011 (talk) 00:21, 4 September 2024 (UTC)Reply
You made the claims in the article that the sources do not support, and have repeatedly edit-warred to retain them. So far you have done nothing to address that problem, except revert those who have. When are you going to fix this situation? --Escape Orbit (Talk) 14:53, 4 September 2024 (UTC)Reply
I refer you to my very first post at the top of this section. To date you have said much, but done nothing, to address these points.
For example, Your preferred version of the article, that you have repeatedly reverted to says "In 2017, the HCDE board voted unanimously to continue operating its 15 Head Start preschool programs, despite some board members proposals to close or limit the department's role, serving approximately 1,300 children in North and Northeast Houston." The cites provided do not so much as even mention Dick in passing, so his involvement in it is unverifiable. Please fix this.
Another example; "Under Eric Dick's direction, significant improvements have been made to Harris County's educational services, with noteworthy projects including the construction of Texas's largest adult learning center, a brand new middle school, and upgrades to existing facilities." The first source for this is Dick's own website, so its proportioning of credit could be questioned. The second cite, a third party and therefore much preferred, never mentions Dick at all. This is all content that is better suited to the HCDE article, and if your concern was about improving Wikipedia, as it should be alone, you would move it to that article instead. Are you going to do this?
I urge you to stop talking about fixing the article, and do it. You have my full support in doing that, as long as you do not resort to synthesis and original research, as I have also previously explained. I also urge you to stop insisting that others must "research" to support what you have added. No one else is obliged to do anything to fix what you have failed to do.--Escape Orbit (Talk) 08:47, 5 September 2024 (UTC)Reply

Scott free0011, I think it's pretty clear to everyone that you have a COI with the subject, and that you are editing promotionally while obfuscating on this talk page with possibly AI-generated wikilawyering, in an attempt to stonewall a real discussion. I also find it distasteful that you would lecture seasoned editors with statements like "The Role of Due Diligence in Editing". No, I am not going to provide a detailed response to every individual edit or request you have made, and I hope other editors likewise don't see the relevance in dumping even more effort into this time sink. Drmies (talk) 23:37, 5 September 2024 (UTC)Reply

That's pretty rude. Starpizza (talk) 03:06, 6 September 2024 (UTC)Reply